Florida's hurricane season brings with it a major concern for homeowners: roof damage. While it's tempting to "just fix what's broken," in many cases, a repair may be a band-aid solution, especially after a severe storm. At Ridgeback Builders, we help homeowners in Fort Myers, Sarasota, Naples, and surrounding areas assess whether a roof repair or full replacement is the smarter long-term choice.
Case Study: Fort Myers Roof Replacement After Hurricane Damage
The Rodriguez family in Fort Myers had a 15-year-old asphalt shingle roof. After Hurricane Milton, they noticed missing shingles, and water spots on the ceiling. They weren't sure whether to repair or replace — and their insurance company had sent a confusing report.
Here's how Ridgeback Builders handled it:
Step 1: Structural Assessment & Insurance Support
Our project manager conducted a full inspection:
- Missing shingles: over 30% of the roof
- Exposed decking with visible water stains
- Moisture detected in attic insulation
- Trusses showing signs of warping
We created a comprehensive damage report, annotated it with photos and measurements, and assisted the homeowner in submitting it to their insurance carrier.
Step 2: Repair vs. Replacement Decision
We compared both options side-by-side:
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Repair | Lower upfront cost | Doesn't address hidden damage, shorter life, no manufacturer warranty |
| Full Replacement | Stronger structure, warranty-backed, long-term value | Higher initial investment |
Step 3: Roof Replacement
We replaced the roof with:
- Temporary tarp coverage to prevent further leaks
- Architectural shingles rated for 130 mph wind
- Underlayment for moisture resistance
- New flashing and ridge venting
- Complete removal of previous shingles, and underlayment
Result:
A stronger, safer, better-ventilated roof that increased the home's value and energy efficiency.
How to Know If You Need Roof Repair or Replacement
| Symptom | What It Suggests |
|---|---|
| Shingles missing in large areas | Likely full replacement |
| Leaks in multiple rooms | Possible decking damage |
| Roof older than 15 years | Near the end of the lifespan |
| Curling, buckling shingles | Moisture and heat damage |
| Light in the attic | Structural compromise |
Why Trust Ridgeback Builders?
- ✅ Licensed Florida contractors
- ✅ Specialize in hurricane roof damage & insurance restoration
- ✅ Fast and knowledgeable roofing inspectors
- ✅ Serving Lehigh Acres, Tampa, Fort Myers, Bradenton, Sarasota, Port St. Lucie, and more
Bonus: Insurance Help Without the Headache
We help homeowners:
- File claims
- Prepare documentation
- Communicate with adjusters
- Maximize what insurance will cover
you're not alone in this — Ridgeback Builders stands with Florida homeowners after every storm.
If your roof took damage during this hurricane season, Don't wait for leaks to turn into mold and rot. Let Ridgeback Builders inspect your roof, explain your options, and provide a written estimate for insurance or personal use.
Contact us today — we serve Lehigh Acres, Fort Myers, Naples, Sarasota, Tampa, Bradenton, West Palm Beach, and nearby cities with pride and precision.